Translation of an original article · 2008
I think the previous section has already made it clear how an engineering approach differs from the approach you might be offered by a “one-stop” design, service and installation company.
So here are the stages:
- Justifying the need for energy.
- Efficiency of use.
- Saving money and providing comfort.
Instead of proceeding through stages 1–2–3 and solving the problem step by step, you will usually be asked to choose light bulbs (air conditioners or boilers) before anyone asks whether you need them at all. Selling things is more profitable than thinking things through.
The first stage alone may be half the necessary work. I focus on the original source of the problem; this helps ensure the intended result while minimizing the cost of implementing my projects. Sometimes it gets ridiculous: while investigating the need, we discover that the client already has everything required. So the need is not as obvious as it looks. You must keep the original justification in sight so you know when to stop pursuing the goal.
This approach is not as simple as the “package deals” offered by many companies in the HVAC market, but it is more effective, more interesting as a process, and brings satisfaction to me as the contractor and benefit to the customer.
The second stage — assessing efficiency — means ensuring that your equipment operates according to its stated specifications. It includes, but is not limited to:
- Choosing rationally. You should buy and install (or attempt to use what you already have) the pieces of hardware that suit your needs, not the ones with the brightest labels. That takes experience and knowledge of the market. Identical products can be sold at remarkably different prices.
- Timely and thorough maintenance. What you bought sometimes needs cleaning, sometimes refilling, sometimes an oil change. Occasionally, something needs repairing. All for one purpose: to make the equipment operate with the efficiency and reliability promised by the manufacturer.
- Periodic measurements and adjustment. These generally happen for one of three reasons:
- during an emergency repair;
- following maintenance;
- at legally or technically required intervals (routine inspections and calibration).
- Rational control. Under contemporary Ukrainian building standards (and, as you may imagine, what is still written into our standards has long been elementary practice elsewhere), every heating radiator should have a thermostatic head. This allows you, whatever the boiler setting, at least to avoid overheating the room you are in and, more importantly, to avoid heating radiators whose warmth is not needed (while preventing them from freezing in winter). There is no reason to heat an unoccupied hotel room, or your home in winter when you have gone on holiday. Nor is there a reason to maintain +18°C in an office during weekends and public holidays.
It is difficult to predict the savings that the second-stage measures may bring. Once, when I investigated excessive gas consumption by a floor-standing Viessmann boiler, the saving reached 40%. The main cause was the complete absence of initial commissioning.
Installing a programmable thermostat that follows the building’s usage schedule, or weather-compensated control of the gas boiler, may save 10% of gas consumption.
Thermostatic radiator valves could bring another 10% if none had been installed before.
Choosing the right gas boiler could reduce operating costs by as much as 15%.
And many more wonders and discoveries await — through enlightenment, experience born of difficult mistakes, genius befriending paradox, and chance as the god of invention.
Many people start their work from the third stage, which they sum up as “we want to be very, very comfortable for as little money as possible”.
This is a philosophical question.
I place it last, and here is why.
Absolutely everything you pay for should bring benefit or comfort. We are not people who pay others to hurt us, are we? ))
I therefore regard comfort as something self-evident. Say we install an ordinary split-system air conditioner. There are two ways to get it wrong: position it so that cold air blows onto your workplace, or choose a system with insufficient capacity.
Otherwise, you can achieve the desired comfort by turning the temperature up or down on the remote control.
The split-system example is simple and calls for proper equipment selection at the second stage. In more complex systems, the extent of your participation in choosing components depends on your ability and willingness to make an informed choice. If you have neither the time nor the opportunity, I make the decisions.
In the following sections I will examine particular cases of the second stage — the efficient use of engineering systems for ventilation, air conditioning and heating.
This historical article preserves the author’s contemporary references to standards, prices and estimated savings.
Original in Russian · All articles in the series
All articles in the series
- What Is Energy Conservation? An Engineering Approach
- Energy Conservation: General Principles and the Creative Process
- Justifying the Need: Do We Need Energy Before We Can Save It?
- Reducing Heat Losses
- Managing Heating Systems
- Which Is Cheaper for Heating: Gas or Electricity?
- Saving Gas: Where Should You Start?
- Energy-Saving Windows
- Energy-saving measures for residential buildings (2014 original in Russian)